I’d honestly choose Plymouth because the Pilgrims were male and female instead of just male. Another reason why I would choose Plymouth is because in 1620 Pilgrims arrived in Plymouth,near Cape Cod,seeking freedom to worship. Plymouth also grew. So I guess that means we had more people!! The Pilgrims had no official Charter,but the Virginians did. Plymouth and Jamestown were the first two permanent English settlements. Both Jamestown and Plymouth suffered greatly in their first few years in North America. So that whole thing is why I would rather live in Plymouth then Jamestown!!!!!